Peer Assessment of Group 18 Peer Assessment of Group 18


Category G11 G12 G13 G14 G15 Average
Visual Appeal 9 9 8 7 8 -
Content 8 8 10 7 9 -
WWW Suitability 9 8 8 8 7 -
Relevance to 210 9 9 9 8 8 -
Personal Gain 8 8 9 8 9 -
TOTAL from Peers 43 42 44 40 41 42
Technical Merit 50+15
TOTAL for GP 107




Evaluation by Group 11
1) evaluators- group 11, "Hot Wings"

2) evaluees- group 18, "Six String"

3) visual appeal- 9
   The sites and homepage were attractive

4) content- 8
   Some of the links were confusing; one link did not exist.  The other
   links were pretty good

5) WWW suitablity- 9
   The molecule was nice.  The group used many of the better Web
   capabilies (sound, etc.)

6) relevence to 210- 9
   Some parts did not relate to organic chemistry as well as we would like
   to see

7) personal gain- 8
   There was not a lot of new information that we had not heard before.

TOTAL SCORE:  43 


Evaluation by Group 12
1. Group 12 - Alkanetraz, 5 evaluators
2. Group 18 - Six String
3. 9
4. 8
5. 8
6. 9
7. 8

We felt the sites were well chosen for their content.


Evaluation by Group 13
Group #18--6 String
        1) Visual Appeal--8
        2) Content--10
        3) WWW Suitability--8
        4) Relevance to Chem210--9
        5) Personal Gain--9

        Total=44
     Comments:  Visual appeal of the sites not overly strong.  In www
suitablility, mostly writing-something that could just as easily show up
on paper for the most part.  A relevant topic to our age group. 


Evaluation by Group 14
Evaluators- Group 14:  Apocalypse

Evaluees-   Group 18:  6-String

Visual Appeal- 7
        The sites provided didn't have a large number of images, but there
were enough.

Content-  7
        The links contained a lot of information but a lot of it was tough
to sort through to find the impotance.

Suitability- 8
        The sites provided seemed fairly reliant on the net, but not
copletely.

Relevance- 8
       Most of the links seemed fairly relevant to chem 210, but it was a
little hard to find.

Personal Gain- 8
       The Group learned a decent amount about steroids from this project.


Evaluation by Group 15
1) Group 15:  The Unknowns

2) Group 18:  Six String

3) Visual Appeal:         8

4) Content of Site:       9

5) WWW Suitability:       7

6) Relavance to Chem 210: 8

7) Personal Gain:         9

                Total:    41

We liked the link to the sex.  One of your sites did not work.  The ladies
liked the pictures of the semi nude guy.