Peer Assessment of Group 17 Peer Assessment of Group 17


Category G11 G12 G13 G14 G15 Average
Visual Appeal 9 10 10 9 10 -
Content 9 10 10 8 10 -
WWW Suitability 9 9 10 10 10 -
Relevance to 210 9 9 9 8 9 -
Personal Gain 9 9 9 8 9 -
TOTAL from Peers 45 47 48 43 48 46
Technical Merit 50
TOTAL for GP 96




Evaluation by Group 11
1) Evaluators- group 11, "Hot Wings"

2) Evaluees- group 17, "Catalytic Cretins"

3) visual appeal- 9
   Not only was the homepage attractive, but the sites were also good.  We
   liked the molecule site.

4) content- 9
   The range of information was broad.

5) www suitablity- 9
   The group used all types of web sites

6) relevence to 210- 9
   There was even a recipe for making the compound!

7) personal gain- 9
   It was really informative and interesting although we never plan on
   actually making Ecstacy

TOTAL SCORE: 45


Evaluation by Group 12
1. Group 12-Alkanetraz, 5 evaluators
2. Group 17-Catalytic Creatins
3. 10
4. 10
5. 9
6. 9
7. 9

We were very pleased with this site.  The visual was great and the text
was also
 appealing. Good Job!


Evaluation by Group 13
Group #17--Catalytic Cretins
        1) Visual Appeal--10
        2) Content--10
        3) WWW Suitability--10
        4) Relevance to Chem210--9
        5) Personal Gain--9

        Total=48
     Comments:  Nice visual site-not too extravagent.  Just appealing,
informative, up to task.


Evaluation by Group 14
Evaluators- Group 14: Apocalypse

Evaluees-   Group 17: Catalytic Cretins


Visual Appeal- 9
       All of the sites provided contained interesting images and were fun
to explore.

Content- 8
       The content was good.  It displayed a fairly complete view of
ecstasy.

Suitability- 10
       Things like the molecule pictures were extemely helpful and
definitely seemed best suited to the net.  The whole project seemed well
integrated with the internet.

Relevance- 8
       The relevance to chem 210 was easily seen through the links. Most
of the sites showed some direct relation.

Personal Gain-  8
       The whole group learned a lot about ecstasy from this project.


Evaluation by Group 15

1) Group 15:  The Unknowns

2) Group 17:  Catalytic Cretins

3) Visual Appeal:         10

4) Content of Site:       10

5) WWW Suitability:       10

6) Relavance to Chem 210:  9

7) Personal Gain:          9

                Total:    48

We liked the fish and the "high" artwork and your webpage in general.